About this property

Elegant Accommodations: Come As You Are Inn LLC in Sayville offers adults-only bed and breakfast accommodations with private check-in and check-out services. Each room features air-conditioning, a private bathroom, and modern amenities including a minibar and free WiFi. Relaxing Facilities: Guests can enjoy a saltwater swimming pool with a view, sun terrace, and lush garden. The property also boasts a bar, outdoor fireplace, hot tub, and outdoor seating areas. Additional amenities include bicycle parking and free on-site private parking. Delicious Breakfast: A continental buffet breakfast is served daily, offering fresh pastries, fruits, and juices. The breakfast is highly praised by guests for its quality and variety. Convenient Location: Located 7 km from Long Island MacArthur Airport and 43 km from Splish Splash, the inn provides easy access to local attractions. Highly rated for its attentive host and excellent breakfast.

Couples particularly like the location — they rated it 9.2 for a two-person trip.

Distance in property description is calculated using © OpenStreetMap

Property highlights

Perfect for a 3-night stay!

Top location: Highly rated by recent guests (9.5)

Breakfast info

Continental, Buffet, Breakfast to go

  • Free private parking available on-site


 ! 

Please select one or more options you want to book

Availability

We have no availability here between Wed 15 Oct 2025 and Sat 18 Oct 2025

Select different dates to see more availability

Checking for other dates
Room type
Number of guests
Price
1 large double bed
Not available on our site for your dates
Not available on our site for your dates
Not available on our site for your dates
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Limited supply in Sayville for your dates: 1 bed and breakfast like this is already unavailable on our site

Guest reviews

Categories:

Staff
Facilities
Cleanliness
Comfort
Value for money
Location
Free WiFi

Select topics to read reviews:

Guests who stayed here loved

  • Joon
    United States United States
    It was very good and delicious. The healthy food was pretty good and the service was excellent.
  • Lucy
    United Kingdom United Kingdom
    Mark and Ari were so welcoming, the room was very comfortable and breakfast was delicious - also enjoyed swimming in the pool!
  • Haley
    United States United States
    My sister and I really enjoyed our time here. Ari and Mark were so accommodating. They felt like family immediately. In the morning Ari baked items for breakfast (even early for us since we were on a set schedule )and Mark drove us to the airport...
  • Tony
    United Kingdom United Kingdom
    Breakfast was very nice, and exactly what we wanted. The hosts were very accomdating and nothing was too much trouble.
  • Alejandro
    United States United States
    My stay at “Come As You Are In” was exactly what I needed: comfortable and relaxing. The room was pleasant, and the bed was very comfy, ensuring I slept well. However, what truly made the stay special was **the host**. They were incredibly...
  • Kate
    United States United States
    Access to a beautiful backyard with pool and hot tub!
  • John
    United States United States
    Lovely, clean room and bathroom, delicious breakfast, engaging hosts, service above and beyond the norm
  • Florentina
    Argentina Argentina
    Me encanto la amabilidad de los anfitiriones, la musica de fondo tan armonica, y el desayuno que es absolutamente una maravilla!
  • Michael
    United States United States
    The innkeepers were fantastic and very friendly and hospitable. Enjoyed our stay and wish the weather cooperated better so we could have enjoyed the pool and grounds more!
  • Corbin
    United States United States
    The owners went out of their way to pick us up from the airport upon our arrival and take us to the train station for our departure. Very knowledgeable of the area with lots of advice on places to visit.

Quality rating

Booking.com rated the quality of this property as 4 out of 5 based on factors such as facilities, size, location and services provided.

Hosted by Mark and Ari Engelhardt

9.8
Host review score
Mark and Ari Engelhardt
Serving the LGBTQI community. Property is situated on the South-shore of Suffolk County Long Island. The House is a short distance from the Long Island Railroad to The Ferries to Fire Island (to The Pines and Cherry Grove) from Manhattan Penn Station, or from JFK International Airport/Air Trains.
Sayville, New York is a charming hamlet in the town of Islip. Situated on the South Shore of Long Island, it is about one hour from Manhattan, Penn Station, and approximately one hour to the air train to JFK International Airport. Also, our house is a ten minute drive from MacArthur Airport. In addition to shopping on Main Street, you will find golf at a number of nearby courses, a small beach and park by the Bay, and the Loughlin Vineyard tucked away on the Roosevelt Estate.
Languages spoken: Greek,English,Spanish

Property surroundings

House rules

Come As You Are Inn LLC takes special requests - add in the next step!
Check-in
From 13:00 to 21:00
Guests are required to show a photo identification and credit card upon check-in
Check-out
From 08:00 to 11:00
Cancellation/ prepayment
Cancellation and prepayment policies vary according to accommodation type. Please check what conditions may apply to each option when making your selection.
Children and beds

Child policies

Children are not allowed.

Cot and extra bed policies

Cots and extra beds are not available at this property.

Age restriction
The minimum age for check-in is 21
Pets
Pets are not allowed.
Payments by Booking.com
Booking.com takes your payment on behalf of the property for this stay, but make sure you have cash for any extras once you get there.
Smoking
Smoking is not allowed.
Parties
Parties/events are not allowed
Quiet hours
Guests must be quiet between 00:00 and 06:00.

The fine print

Need-to-know information for guests at this property

Guests are required to show a photo identification and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.

This property will not accommodate hen, stag or similar parties.

Quiet hours are between 00:00:00 and 06:00:00.